Dementia is a gruesome disease.
It robs you of your dearest memories, your personality and sense of self, your vocabulary and communication, function and what you can do, and life. Unlike cancer, there's no drug or surgery or intervention that we have which can prolong life/delay death by even one day.
Broadly dementia is said to cause both cognitive problems (changes in memory and thinking) and non-cognitive problems (behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia, BPSD).
Cognitive changes can be managed, fairly successfully, most of the time. Non-drug strategies (practical support, carer interactions and psychological interventions) make a huge difference. I'm not amazingly sold on Cognitive Stimulation Therapy as the bees knees (that NICE advocate in their clinical guideline CG 42), but a host of simple practical suggestions can help non-demented and demented folk alike, like these. Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors have significant benefits to most folk with Alzheimer's Disease (and related dementias) most of the time. We can't stop cognitive change over time, but we can manage the symptoms of it and the impact of it, fairly well, most of the time.
What's much more problematic is managing the non-cognitive BPSD part. Wandering without purpose day and night, mood changes and frustrations with anxiety or utter unconsolable despair, shrieking and screaming in public, disinhibition trying to kiss strangers and masterbating in public, suspicion of partners/carers with consequent hostility and violence. Much harder to manage than cognitive changes such as forgetting a hairdresser's appointment.
Our weekly carers' support group rarely focuses on cognitive problems, mostly it's BPSD that takes carers to their knees, it's BPSD that they need help managing. Without the intensity of the BPSD they miraculously could (and usually do) cope well in truly dismal circumstances.
Delusions, with paranoid persecutory thoughts, mood disturbance and seemingly irrational beliefs, how can these be managed?
In America the FDA have said, "Antipsychotics are not indicated for the treatment of dementia-related psychosis."
This can be harsh.
You can have psychosis, this can torment the patient and torment the carer, you've antipsychotics to treat the psychosis but you don't. Kind of galls me, that.
The reasoning behind the FDA's reticence to entertain antipsychotic medication in dementia care is sound. It's not homeopathy, it's proper medicine that has proper benefits but also proper risks/side effects (like ramping up risks of a stroke in the next year by 2%). The medications can cause significant harm.
Originally work was mostly focussed on risperidone and olanzapine since there was sufficient research to evidence consequences of use in dementia care (both good and bad), with such medication evidencing great benefit as well as great risk. Subsequent research shows older adults in care homes experience similar risk from which ever antipsychotic drug you use. They all have side effects and can cause harm, it's just some are more likely to cause a heart attack, others more likely a stroke, but the over all risks are pretty comparable.
Knowing that the medication has a modest risk:benefit ratio and can cause significant harm, such medications need to be carefully considered and used judiciuously. Careful consideration of what the issue being treated is, what the target symptoms are, what the level of symptom burden is before treatment, what it is after introducing medication and is there objective gain through the medication's use? The time necessary and sophistication of assessment, reasoning/rational prescribing practice, carer input/management of frequently incapacitated adults (with respect to the treatment decision and valid consent), initiation, titration and evaluation of medication is usually outwith the scope of Primary Care or acute hospitals and sits better within mental health services for older people.
With that in mind, and seeing the grim consequences for patients and carers of not treating BPSD and dementia related psychosis, I'm increasingly aligning with this view, ". . . that antipsychotics may be justified using a palliative model."
Evidence Based Medicine (EBM) informs the discussion but to then elect to use antipsychotic medication, for some patients, some of the time, that somehow feels much more humane.
Showing posts with label Dementia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dementia. Show all posts
Wednesday, 1 June 2011
Friday, 8 October 2010
Dementia Care
I'm sure everyone's been gripped by the NICE review and preliminary guidance on the NICE Technology Appraisal (TA 111), released yesterday. It goes on, at length, here. Reading the runes, it's likely to be refreshed from preliminary guidance into national NICE guidance in February 2011 which then has significant implications. Implementation and use of Technology Appraisals in clinical care has to be funded and can't be denied solely on cost grounds.
I'm rather relieved, therefore, that in my corner it isn't going to make a significant difference. Does the review of TA 111 matter, than? It was released in September 2007, updated in August 2009, now refreshed in October 2010 for update in February 2011. Does this document have any use or meaning? It will, helpfully, to a lot of other Trusts.
Microsoft Word tells me the preliminary guidance is 21 824 words. There's a lot of it.
I like it.
It's at variance with some folks' wishes who aren't keen on early diagnosis, since the guidance now invites treatment of mild dementia, rather than waiting 'til you're moderately demented before starting medication. This makes sense to me. The medication typically holds a person at their level of cognition for couple of years. Is is better to be held at a level where MMSE is 24/30 or where MMSE is 14/30? There're exceptions (where insight is a curse and distress blessedly diminishes as the ability to forget becomes more intense) but usually it's desirable (and desired by patients/carers) to keep someone at their best, rather than wait for a decline then keep them at that level.
This is what my colleagues and I've done for years. Our local Alzheimer's Society, PCT, Area Prescribing Committee, GPs and Trust Medicines Management Committee uncharacteristiclaly all agreed a care pwathway and funding such that folk with dementia access treatment on diagnosis, irrespective of severity/MMSE. All my patients with mild dementia have been having the drugs for years.
No changes there, then. Speaking with colleagues in other Trusts, it will open up a huge amount of work for them, with literally hundreds of people who've mild dementia who will be entitled to medication and aren't currently on it needing review and discussion and (often) medication initiated, titrated, reviewed then continued under Shared Care.
I don't prescribe a lot of memantine, using it with just a few patients, so the guidance there won't change my world. Opening up memantine so it can be used in the NHS (outside of clinical trials) isn't a change for me, since I am prescribing it already.
Over 20 000 words saying I can practice as I am.
That's the sort of guidance I can stand to receive!
I'm rather relieved, therefore, that in my corner it isn't going to make a significant difference. Does the review of TA 111 matter, than? It was released in September 2007, updated in August 2009, now refreshed in October 2010 for update in February 2011. Does this document have any use or meaning? It will, helpfully, to a lot of other Trusts.
Microsoft Word tells me the preliminary guidance is 21 824 words. There's a lot of it.
I like it.
It's at variance with some folks' wishes who aren't keen on early diagnosis, since the guidance now invites treatment of mild dementia, rather than waiting 'til you're moderately demented before starting medication. This makes sense to me. The medication typically holds a person at their level of cognition for couple of years. Is is better to be held at a level where MMSE is 24/30 or where MMSE is 14/30? There're exceptions (where insight is a curse and distress blessedly diminishes as the ability to forget becomes more intense) but usually it's desirable (and desired by patients/carers) to keep someone at their best, rather than wait for a decline then keep them at that level.
This is what my colleagues and I've done for years. Our local Alzheimer's Society, PCT, Area Prescribing Committee, GPs and Trust Medicines Management Committee uncharacteristiclaly all agreed a care pwathway and funding such that folk with dementia access treatment on diagnosis, irrespective of severity/MMSE. All my patients with mild dementia have been having the drugs for years.
No changes there, then. Speaking with colleagues in other Trusts, it will open up a huge amount of work for them, with literally hundreds of people who've mild dementia who will be entitled to medication and aren't currently on it needing review and discussion and (often) medication initiated, titrated, reviewed then continued under Shared Care.
I don't prescribe a lot of memantine, using it with just a few patients, so the guidance there won't change my world. Opening up memantine so it can be used in the NHS (outside of clinical trials) isn't a change for me, since I am prescribing it already.
Over 20 000 words saying I can practice as I am.
That's the sort of guidance I can stand to receive!
Tuesday, 5 October 2010
Vitamin B
Folks with memory problems have some B vitamins checked before ever reaching my door. Vitamin B12 (and folic acid, and LFTs showing albumin levels) evidence nutrition, or lack of nutrition.
If patients have evidence of vitamin deficiency, it's usually treated by their GP before I assess the patient, so assessment of mood and cognition is looking at contributing mental health problems, not nutritional deficits impacting on their wellbeing.
Recently patients' carers have been asking me about vitamin B preventing/slowing Alzheimer's disease. It's not something I know a lot about. I know a lot about Alzheimer's disease, the risk factors, the pathology that develops within the brain, the evidence of psychological interventions and the evidence of medication's efficacy and effectiveness. I know that about 8% of patients referred to me with dementia have something else instead, so routinely find physical health problems presenting with cognitive impairment.
In all this thinking and sleuthing stuff out, I was perturbed that vitamins could have great benefit to my patients but none of my colleagues knew of this, no current teaching articulated this, no past training covered this and no journal articles and updating continuing professional development taught this. My pharmacist colleagues knew naught of this, either. Perplexing.
I spent a few hours finding what I could. A pharmacist did the same. We met up and compared notes. We'd not found anything illuminating.
I chanced upon another blog today for the first time, which helpfully fisks the rubbish being tossed around in some main stream media. It's heartening that it's not just me and my clinical team that's not wondrously excited by vitamin B.
When patients ask about it, I'm indifferent. It's cheap, it's water soluble (so, unless really really trying hard, if you take too much it is dissolved in our urine and we just wee it out) but it's also not convincingly beneficial. If it's taken with minerals (like iron) then it's not that hard for folk with dementia to poison themselves.
It's not crystal therapy or colour healing. Not quite. It could have some sensible contribution beyond placebo effect. If people want to take vitamin B, all well and good. But it's not something my GPs or I'm prescribing for folk with dementia, yet.
If patients have evidence of vitamin deficiency, it's usually treated by their GP before I assess the patient, so assessment of mood and cognition is looking at contributing mental health problems, not nutritional deficits impacting on their wellbeing.
Recently patients' carers have been asking me about vitamin B preventing/slowing Alzheimer's disease. It's not something I know a lot about. I know a lot about Alzheimer's disease, the risk factors, the pathology that develops within the brain, the evidence of psychological interventions and the evidence of medication's efficacy and effectiveness. I know that about 8% of patients referred to me with dementia have something else instead, so routinely find physical health problems presenting with cognitive impairment.
In all this thinking and sleuthing stuff out, I was perturbed that vitamins could have great benefit to my patients but none of my colleagues knew of this, no current teaching articulated this, no past training covered this and no journal articles and updating continuing professional development taught this. My pharmacist colleagues knew naught of this, either. Perplexing.
I spent a few hours finding what I could. A pharmacist did the same. We met up and compared notes. We'd not found anything illuminating.
I chanced upon another blog today for the first time, which helpfully fisks the rubbish being tossed around in some main stream media. It's heartening that it's not just me and my clinical team that's not wondrously excited by vitamin B.
When patients ask about it, I'm indifferent. It's cheap, it's water soluble (so, unless really really trying hard, if you take too much it is dissolved in our urine and we just wee it out) but it's also not convincingly beneficial. If it's taken with minerals (like iron) then it's not that hard for folk with dementia to poison themselves.
It's not crystal therapy or colour healing. Not quite. It could have some sensible contribution beyond placebo effect. If people want to take vitamin B, all well and good. But it's not something my GPs or I'm prescribing for folk with dementia, yet.
Friday, 1 October 2010
Surprise
I was surprised.
When the National Dementia Strategy was published in February 2009, although it wasn't a vision of perfection, it had good content and importantly also had cash attached to it. Strategic Health Authorities were given millions to implement the strategy. Not just "these are good ideas" or "do more, and now start doing it right" but instead a sensible strategy with sensible amounts of cash to resource it.
I was pleased.
Okay, okay, in my corner our Trust didn't get a penny more, but had (and still have) to deliver on objectives, so are being asked to do more and mroe without anything extra. But across Primary Care and the Local Authority and care homes, new money has been thrown at it and has helped patients. Mostly with Continuing Care funding, it seems.
I am still pleased.
That was February 2009. Time moves on. 1 year 8 months on and it's all gone quiet, with no enthusiasm to tackle dementia and the focus has moved elsewhere. No no no. This week the Department of Health published another document, following on from the National Dementia Strategy, called Quality outcomes for people with dementia : Builing on the work of the National Dementia Strategy. Okay, it's not the snappiest title for a document, but what's the document about? Read it on the DoH website, here.
It only came out this week, on the 28th September, so I've only just got around to reading it, thinking about it and forming a view. It contains 9 desired outcomes for people with dementia, which are clear and meaningful and realistic. It gives explanation of how theese outcomes can be delivered without oodles of prescriptive mandates and This Is What Thou Shalt Do edicts. Even the appendix, Annex 1, gives genuinely helpful descriptors for what the 9 outcomes/improvements for patients with dementia mean, in a nutshell.
First there's a National Dementia Strategy with a clear, over arching vision for health and social welfare that had millions attached to it, that we got. Then there's a follow up document a year and a half on, maintaining focus and contributing useful outcomes.
I remain pleased. Pleased and very pleasantly surprised.
When the National Dementia Strategy was published in February 2009, although it wasn't a vision of perfection, it had good content and importantly also had cash attached to it. Strategic Health Authorities were given millions to implement the strategy. Not just "these are good ideas" or "do more, and now start doing it right" but instead a sensible strategy with sensible amounts of cash to resource it.
I was pleased.
Okay, okay, in my corner our Trust didn't get a penny more, but had (and still have) to deliver on objectives, so are being asked to do more and mroe without anything extra. But across Primary Care and the Local Authority and care homes, new money has been thrown at it and has helped patients. Mostly with Continuing Care funding, it seems.
I am still pleased.
That was February 2009. Time moves on. 1 year 8 months on and it's all gone quiet, with no enthusiasm to tackle dementia and the focus has moved elsewhere. No no no. This week the Department of Health published another document, following on from the National Dementia Strategy, called Quality outcomes for people with dementia : Builing on the work of the National Dementia Strategy. Okay, it's not the snappiest title for a document, but what's the document about? Read it on the DoH website, here.
It only came out this week, on the 28th September, so I've only just got around to reading it, thinking about it and forming a view. It contains 9 desired outcomes for people with dementia, which are clear and meaningful and realistic. It gives explanation of how theese outcomes can be delivered without oodles of prescriptive mandates and This Is What Thou Shalt Do edicts. Even the appendix, Annex 1, gives genuinely helpful descriptors for what the 9 outcomes/improvements for patients with dementia mean, in a nutshell.
First there's a National Dementia Strategy with a clear, over arching vision for health and social welfare that had millions attached to it, that we got. Then there's a follow up document a year and a half on, maintaining focus and contributing useful outcomes.
I remain pleased. Pleased and very pleasantly surprised.
Friday, 24 September 2010
Orientation
A nurse and I were in a patient's house, talking with a widowed gentleman who'd apparently not been faring brilliantly.
He has diabetes and hypertension and hyperlipidaemia, presumably these have contributed to his vascular dementia. Mostly he manages pretty well, with support. He is keen to stay in his own home and his social worker's sorted out care for him 3 times a day (he was unable to manage his medicines, so needs home care to prompt with that, as well as support meals and drinks), he attends a day centre once a week where he gets a bath and has some new fangled telecare that means if he leaves his home at night and doesn't come back after a few minutes, his daughter's automatically 'phoned. He's never yet wandered at night, but it's a sensible precaution.
Having vascular dementia there's not a lot that I can personally do. The GP has sorted his physical health and the risk factors. His social worker has sorted practical care. A nurse went through information with him and his family, over a few weeks.
We found ourselves in his home because a new home carer had alerted her manager that he was unwell, confused and "had it in" for his brothers. Homicidal thoughts. High risk. A 'phone call to us sought an urgent review. We knew it wasn't urgent, but we were in the area so popped in to see him.
It was clear he had no new psychiatric problems (in particular there were no mood changes and no persecutory beliefs) and no new physical health symptoms. He was stable and much the same as I'd seen him a year or so ago, when I first saw him for initial assessment and diagnosis. The nurse, who's seen him too, was talking through with him what home care had said of him thinking badly of his brothers.
"Aye," he said, "the both of 'em have been having it away with a lass, she's only 18!" He was mortified that they'd got her pregnant. The nurse looked at him and without even blinking said, "Let's have a look at that, shall we? Your brothers, are they still alive?" We knew his history.
The man paused for a fraction of a second, confusion then surprise then a smile shifting across his face. "No, they're both dead, been dead for years, love. Why'd that daft thought come into my head, then?!"
The nurse had sorted it. There was no homicidal risk. There was no psychiatric illness for me to fiddle with, nothing specific for me to do. But it was still an oddly satisfying visit.
He has diabetes and hypertension and hyperlipidaemia, presumably these have contributed to his vascular dementia. Mostly he manages pretty well, with support. He is keen to stay in his own home and his social worker's sorted out care for him 3 times a day (he was unable to manage his medicines, so needs home care to prompt with that, as well as support meals and drinks), he attends a day centre once a week where he gets a bath and has some new fangled telecare that means if he leaves his home at night and doesn't come back after a few minutes, his daughter's automatically 'phoned. He's never yet wandered at night, but it's a sensible precaution.
Having vascular dementia there's not a lot that I can personally do. The GP has sorted his physical health and the risk factors. His social worker has sorted practical care. A nurse went through information with him and his family, over a few weeks.
We found ourselves in his home because a new home carer had alerted her manager that he was unwell, confused and "had it in" for his brothers. Homicidal thoughts. High risk. A 'phone call to us sought an urgent review. We knew it wasn't urgent, but we were in the area so popped in to see him.
It was clear he had no new psychiatric problems (in particular there were no mood changes and no persecutory beliefs) and no new physical health symptoms. He was stable and much the same as I'd seen him a year or so ago, when I first saw him for initial assessment and diagnosis. The nurse, who's seen him too, was talking through with him what home care had said of him thinking badly of his brothers.
"Aye," he said, "the both of 'em have been having it away with a lass, she's only 18!" He was mortified that they'd got her pregnant. The nurse looked at him and without even blinking said, "Let's have a look at that, shall we? Your brothers, are they still alive?" We knew his history.
The man paused for a fraction of a second, confusion then surprise then a smile shifting across his face. "No, they're both dead, been dead for years, love. Why'd that daft thought come into my head, then?!"
The nurse had sorted it. There was no homicidal risk. There was no psychiatric illness for me to fiddle with, nothing specific for me to do. But it was still an oddly satisfying visit.
Thursday, 3 June 2010
Hospitals
Times are changing. Allegedly. Although maybe not changing an awful lot, since our PCT 'fessed up today that the money the SHA has given them for the implementation of the National Dementia Strategy, not being ring fenced, has been swallowed up by other stuff and spent on other things. So it goes.
Cash that could have been used to improve dementia care therefore's evaporated and the acute Trust down the road grumbles along, despite the national picture reported by the Alzheimer's Society showing that, well, it's all a bit shabby.
Is there any hope, then? Locally, the acute Trust is working with us and is keen to improve. There's a lot of work to be done, though. For example, the DoH have accepted Prof Banerjee's report and recommendations around antipsychotic prescribing in dementia care. 180 000 patients with dementia on such drugs with only 36 000 getting benefit rightly raises concern that prescribing practice needs to be more robust. How're things to improve? Exceptionally and very hearteningly, there's no requirement for more committees and no desire for more management. The report requires that Medical Directors and existing governance structures deliver on this. Deliver on what? Just one bit of one recommendation is that the Trust has to ensure good practice in initiating medication. And ensure good practice if it's maintained (e.g. a patient comes in on it and the hospital ward continues to administer it to them). And ensure good practice in discontinuing medication. All sensible stuff.
What's intrigues me more is that in addition to the clinical quality improving, there Trust has to ensure this is done. So just bashing out some protocols or care pathways or policies or naming a couple Dementia Champions or Medicines Management Champions or Lead Practitioners or having a standard operating procedure or drafting guidance ain't enough. They need to ensure that the system works. First the clinical care has to improve, then evidence of this meaningful implementation needs to be generated. Without more managers or committees or nonsense.
Having met with PCT and LA and colleagues today, I am hopeful. But the acute Trust having to do this, with no new cash 'cause the PCT snaffled it . . . somehow this seems less than ideal.
Cash that could have been used to improve dementia care therefore's evaporated and the acute Trust down the road grumbles along, despite the national picture reported by the Alzheimer's Society showing that, well, it's all a bit shabby.
Is there any hope, then? Locally, the acute Trust is working with us and is keen to improve. There's a lot of work to be done, though. For example, the DoH have accepted Prof Banerjee's report and recommendations around antipsychotic prescribing in dementia care. 180 000 patients with dementia on such drugs with only 36 000 getting benefit rightly raises concern that prescribing practice needs to be more robust. How're things to improve? Exceptionally and very hearteningly, there's no requirement for more committees and no desire for more management. The report requires that Medical Directors and existing governance structures deliver on this. Deliver on what? Just one bit of one recommendation is that the Trust has to ensure good practice in initiating medication. And ensure good practice if it's maintained (e.g. a patient comes in on it and the hospital ward continues to administer it to them). And ensure good practice in discontinuing medication. All sensible stuff.
What's intrigues me more is that in addition to the clinical quality improving, there Trust has to ensure this is done. So just bashing out some protocols or care pathways or policies or naming a couple Dementia Champions or Medicines Management Champions or Lead Practitioners or having a standard operating procedure or drafting guidance ain't enough. They need to ensure that the system works. First the clinical care has to improve, then evidence of this meaningful implementation needs to be generated. Without more managers or committees or nonsense.
Having met with PCT and LA and colleagues today, I am hopeful. But the acute Trust having to do this, with no new cash 'cause the PCT snaffled it . . . somehow this seems less than ideal.
Thursday, 27 May 2010
Care Pathways
I saw a patient with dementia. He was wandering on evenings, couldn't manage his money any more, couldn't sort food for himself and couldn't maintain his property adequately.
He was seen by a CMHT nurse and myself. Assessment was clear. CT imaging confirmed atrophic change. A diagnosis of a neurodegenerative dementia, almost certainly Alzheimer's disease, was made. He had 16 interventions made on his care plan including Council Tax exemption, advice to sort out two LPAs, getting his will sorted, a monitored dosage system, reducing meds, benefits check, three Home Care visits a day, DVLA notification and selling his car, Social Work follow up to review care schedules, nurse visits to family for carer education and support, telecare for a pendant alarm and to alert family if he's opening doors after 10.00pm, an FP10 for galantamine, ongoing follow up for review, day Memory Therapy Services for CST, follow up with me for titration/review of Rx, advice to him/his family on local Alzheimer's Society resources. Usually we provide decent care for folk with dementia, a regional report has us as a beacon service. All well and good.
I saw a patient with dementia. He was wandering on evenings, couldn't manage his money any more, couldn't sort food for himself and couldn't maintain his property adequately.
He was seen by a CMHT nurse and myself. Assessment was clear. CT imaging confirmed vascular damage. A diagnosis of a vascular damage was made. The care pathway is then refer to Primary Care to manage, who can refer to neurology and stroke outreach if necessary (who have no social work and no community services, at all). He had 2 interventions on his care plan, basic advice given and discharge to Primary Care.
Somehow, for both people to have the same sort of experiences, yielding the same consequent deficits, but profoundly different support, stirs disquiet . . .
He was seen by a CMHT nurse and myself. Assessment was clear. CT imaging confirmed atrophic change. A diagnosis of a neurodegenerative dementia, almost certainly Alzheimer's disease, was made. He had 16 interventions made on his care plan including Council Tax exemption, advice to sort out two LPAs, getting his will sorted, a monitored dosage system, reducing meds, benefits check, three Home Care visits a day, DVLA notification and selling his car, Social Work follow up to review care schedules, nurse visits to family for carer education and support, telecare for a pendant alarm and to alert family if he's opening doors after 10.00pm, an FP10 for galantamine, ongoing follow up for review, day Memory Therapy Services for CST, follow up with me for titration/review of Rx, advice to him/his family on local Alzheimer's Society resources. Usually we provide decent care for folk with dementia, a regional report has us as a beacon service. All well and good.
I saw a patient with dementia. He was wandering on evenings, couldn't manage his money any more, couldn't sort food for himself and couldn't maintain his property adequately.
He was seen by a CMHT nurse and myself. Assessment was clear. CT imaging confirmed vascular damage. A diagnosis of a vascular damage was made. The care pathway is then refer to Primary Care to manage, who can refer to neurology and stroke outreach if necessary (who have no social work and no community services, at all). He had 2 interventions on his care plan, basic advice given and discharge to Primary Care.
Somehow, for both people to have the same sort of experiences, yielding the same consequent deficits, but profoundly different support, stirs disquiet . . .
Thursday, 15 April 2010
Fridges
How do you practice psychiatry in hospitals, and clinics, as folk in the USA mostly do, with folk who have dementia?
I ask in the spirit of genuine inquiry since I find visiting folk at home to be a core and wholly necessary part of work. The bit that's most useful is, of course, the patient's fridge.
It's always good to look in a fridge, I find.
There's the opportunity to see what food and drink's in it. One once was stacked full (so full you couldn't see the fridge light at the top) of beer. An opportunity to talk about alcohol use and the amount drunk.
One had nothing in it but milk for tea and plasticky cheese slices. An opportunity to talk about diet and opportunistic health promotion.
One today had a mix of things. Greens, mostly. But not in a good way. The fridge was filled with food that was covered in green fur. Or, on some of it, black mould. In addition to the varied diet of mouldy food (the food long since obliterated so I've no idea what it originally was), was what Withnail and I would call, "matter."
Just semi solid stuff, composting down, with dark greenish black fluid seeping out of the bottom.
An opportunity to talk about a suboptimal level of function.
You can look in a fridge and see if food's out of date. "What is the date today, is this in date?" An opportunity to test orientation and decision making, without abstract instruments irrelevant to our patients but instead with tests of ecological validity.
Using fridges works too. "Fancy a cup of tea, doc?" "Why yes, thank you kindly, I rather would." Do they go straight for the tea or hunt around several cupboards for it? Do they sequence with cold water in the kettle, then heat it, then mix hot water with tea, leave it to brew (but not for too short or too long a time), place the hot tea in a cup, add milk, all in the right pace and order? Is there a tremour? Do they get muddled? Is the milk in date? An opportunity to talk about organisation and sequencing.
Seeing someone at home, seeing what's in their fridge and how they use it, beats 20 minutes of questions in clinic any day!
I ask in the spirit of genuine inquiry since I find visiting folk at home to be a core and wholly necessary part of work. The bit that's most useful is, of course, the patient's fridge.
It's always good to look in a fridge, I find.
There's the opportunity to see what food and drink's in it. One once was stacked full (so full you couldn't see the fridge light at the top) of beer. An opportunity to talk about alcohol use and the amount drunk.
One had nothing in it but milk for tea and plasticky cheese slices. An opportunity to talk about diet and opportunistic health promotion.
One today had a mix of things. Greens, mostly. But not in a good way. The fridge was filled with food that was covered in green fur. Or, on some of it, black mould. In addition to the varied diet of mouldy food (the food long since obliterated so I've no idea what it originally was), was what Withnail and I would call, "matter."
Just semi solid stuff, composting down, with dark greenish black fluid seeping out of the bottom.
An opportunity to talk about a suboptimal level of function.
You can look in a fridge and see if food's out of date. "What is the date today, is this in date?" An opportunity to test orientation and decision making, without abstract instruments irrelevant to our patients but instead with tests of ecological validity.
Using fridges works too. "Fancy a cup of tea, doc?" "Why yes, thank you kindly, I rather would." Do they go straight for the tea or hunt around several cupboards for it? Do they sequence with cold water in the kettle, then heat it, then mix hot water with tea, leave it to brew (but not for too short or too long a time), place the hot tea in a cup, add milk, all in the right pace and order? Is there a tremour? Do they get muddled? Is the milk in date? An opportunity to talk about organisation and sequencing.
Seeing someone at home, seeing what's in their fridge and how they use it, beats 20 minutes of questions in clinic any day!
Thursday, 28 January 2010
Acute care
Dr Kirsten posed a sensible question, here, asking how could a patient with delirium be managed better.
I'll post on that, later.
It did get me wondering though, why the question wasn't reversed. Why wasn't an old age psychiatrist asking Dr Kirsten for the advice. No, really, think about it. Our psychiatric hospital has less than a dozen patients with dementia on the wards. Our neighbouring acute hospital Trust has, across it's medical and surgical wards, a lot more. Statistically, I'd expect them to have 334 patients who are older adults with dementia in their beds, today.
334.
That's a lot.
That's common place, that's who they have to look after, each and every day, on their wards. We have less than a dozen on ours.
In-patient care of older adults with dementia; who should the experts be?
I'll post on that, later.
It did get me wondering though, why the question wasn't reversed. Why wasn't an old age psychiatrist asking Dr Kirsten for the advice. No, really, think about it. Our psychiatric hospital has less than a dozen patients with dementia on the wards. Our neighbouring acute hospital Trust has, across it's medical and surgical wards, a lot more. Statistically, I'd expect them to have 334 patients who are older adults with dementia in their beds, today.
334.
That's a lot.
That's common place, that's who they have to look after, each and every day, on their wards. We have less than a dozen on ours.
In-patient care of older adults with dementia; who should the experts be?
Saturday, 23 January 2010
Ward doctors
Ward nurses are busy. Medical and surgical wards I visit don't have the staff to do the work that's needed. It's manifestly evident to everyone, but since it costs to pay for more nurses, wards are chronically under-resourced. Our mental health wards are not, thankfully, with a 2:1 patient:staff ratio at the moment.
We staff wards sufficiently 'cause that's what we need to get the work done. Any less and we have worse outcomes.
Our neighbouring acute Trust seems to enjoy collecting data from their medical and surgical directorates. Almost as much as it enjoys documenting events, or non-events. Curiously, it thinks the best people to do this aren't clerical staff or IT staff or medical informatics folk, they reckon it's best to get the nurses to do it. One perk of having nurses on the wards is that they can provide nursing care. On the acute hospital site, I don't see nurses doing a whole heap of nursing now ('cept for the neuro rehab site where they're delightfully anarchic and simply crack on and sort patients, huzzah!) since they're mired in process and paperwork. The Productive Ward has sought to reduce this, but largely hasn't worked on their wards, instead it's generated more process. Ho hum. Maybe it'll get better. They've got less front line nurses and even more Modern Matron managers to sort this out.
Yesterday I saw a lady presenting with confusion, on a medical ward. She had a chest infection, against a background of worsening chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. She had dementia. She had no idea where she was, who was around her, why she was there, how long she'd been there, what was happening, what the different kit around her and the other 3 ladies in her bay was. She had no notion of what day it was, or what time of day.
Ward staff found her difficult to manage, since every 15 to 20 minutes or so she'd anxiously walk to the nursing station, loiter until a nurse passed by, then ask them what she should be doing. It took them time to talk with her. Time they did not have, since their Trust mires them with process that's seemingly more valued than the direct clinical care. They wanted to, but were rushed, they knew they weren't giving her the time she needed and deserved. Much frustration.
But when I saw her, she was settled. She wasn't wandering around the ward, seeking reassaurance any more. She wasn't even sat out in her chair, she was still in her bed. Because the nursing staff had been frazzled, so moaned to the junior doctor. The ward doctor is very young and very inexperienced and has no notion of person centred dementia care. The ward doctor is a doctor and she can prescribe. Haloperidol 10mg had been given, which had flattened her. Spectacularly. Well it would, being about x10 the dose we'd normally give, but ho hum. She was then lying in bed, keeping her nasal cannula on, causing no problems what so ever.
The junior doctor knows no better and can't. She's still too junior.
I get that the junior doctor has to support her nursing colleagues when they're fraught and frazzled. Yet, treating the staff's agenda to the detriment of the patient seems a step too far.
We staff wards sufficiently 'cause that's what we need to get the work done. Any less and we have worse outcomes.
Our neighbouring acute Trust seems to enjoy collecting data from their medical and surgical directorates. Almost as much as it enjoys documenting events, or non-events. Curiously, it thinks the best people to do this aren't clerical staff or IT staff or medical informatics folk, they reckon it's best to get the nurses to do it. One perk of having nurses on the wards is that they can provide nursing care. On the acute hospital site, I don't see nurses doing a whole heap of nursing now ('cept for the neuro rehab site where they're delightfully anarchic and simply crack on and sort patients, huzzah!) since they're mired in process and paperwork. The Productive Ward has sought to reduce this, but largely hasn't worked on their wards, instead it's generated more process. Ho hum. Maybe it'll get better. They've got less front line nurses and even more Modern Matron managers to sort this out.
Yesterday I saw a lady presenting with confusion, on a medical ward. She had a chest infection, against a background of worsening chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. She had dementia. She had no idea where she was, who was around her, why she was there, how long she'd been there, what was happening, what the different kit around her and the other 3 ladies in her bay was. She had no notion of what day it was, or what time of day.
Ward staff found her difficult to manage, since every 15 to 20 minutes or so she'd anxiously walk to the nursing station, loiter until a nurse passed by, then ask them what she should be doing. It took them time to talk with her. Time they did not have, since their Trust mires them with process that's seemingly more valued than the direct clinical care. They wanted to, but were rushed, they knew they weren't giving her the time she needed and deserved. Much frustration.
But when I saw her, she was settled. She wasn't wandering around the ward, seeking reassaurance any more. She wasn't even sat out in her chair, she was still in her bed. Because the nursing staff had been frazzled, so moaned to the junior doctor. The ward doctor is very young and very inexperienced and has no notion of person centred dementia care. The ward doctor is a doctor and she can prescribe. Haloperidol 10mg had been given, which had flattened her. Spectacularly. Well it would, being about x10 the dose we'd normally give, but ho hum. She was then lying in bed, keeping her nasal cannula on, causing no problems what so ever.
The junior doctor knows no better and can't. She's still too junior.
I get that the junior doctor has to support her nursing colleagues when they're fraught and frazzled. Yet, treating the staff's agenda to the detriment of the patient seems a step too far.
Thursday, 21 January 2010
Monday, 14 September 2009
Benzodiazepines
I've differing views on the use of lorazepam and other benzodiazepines (here and here).
The Jobbing Doctor has quite rightly highlighted how mental health can be overly zealous in dishing out lorazepam. Got me thinking.
Bit of a delay in getting an answer to this one since it got me hassling a pharmacist to suss things out for me.
The outcomes were rather heartening.
Most patients prescribed lorazepam within my corner receive it as part of an adjunct to their dementia care. By "most patients" I in fact mean all of them. I have two patients who are prescribed a benzodiazepine for anxiety states. Every other patient on a benzodiazepine is taking it as a part of their package of dementia care.
One lady has anxiety which necessitated hospital in-patient care over many months, she relocated to my corner a few years ago to be near to family and now is on oxazepam 5mg as required. The tablets are 10mg, so it's half a tablet a time. The dose range in older adults is 10mg to 20mg, 3 or 4 times a day. 30mg to 80mg a day, then (which is what she was taking when we first met). She now takes 5mg a couple times a week. At such a tiny dose there's no risk of pharmacological dependence, no problems of side effects. Okay okay, it's homeopathy in all but name, yet for her it's invaluable. She finds that when she's anxious she can take half a tablet, she's in control, it's a key tool for her in her toolbox as part of her anxiety management. Developing an internal locus of control, patient choice, an empowered patient, person centred care, frame it how you will. For her, being able to have a bottle of tablets with just one tablet used up each week is incredibly effective in enabling her to manage her mood state and functional level.
Another lady's had a major adjustment disorder and is currently taking diazepam 2mg half to one tablet once a day. Again, a dose that doesn't cause pharmacological dependence (or side effects for her) but a dose which gives her feelings of relief that she finds necessary to help her cope. And cope she does, now managing activities of daily living that six months ago eluded her. Sure, her CBT and SNRI and twice weekly CPN input are far more meaningful than a sniff of diazepam, but for her the choice of taking a dose (or not) when she wishes is a choice that she feels she needs, a choice that puts her back in control, a choice that enables her to feel she's better equipped to cope.
Other than these two patients, every other prescription for a benzodiazepine since April has been purely as an aid in the management of dementia care. It's not used a lot, at all. We've specialist teams to support care in my corner so if there're problems then the team looks at causes and understanding and interventions, I look at physical comorbidity and concurrent medication, our commonest intervention is stopping drugs not starting them.
I still find it amazing how much medication is used for the right reasons at the right time, but then when dementia progresses the medication's side effect profile and tolerability generate treatment emergent adverse events (e.g. wailing, sobbing, battering carers) which a GP and I can improve upon through review and rationalising a drug regimen.
But if you've dementia, and this advances to cause the inevitable cognitive decline but also non-cognitive changes (i.e. behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia, BPSD), and these are intense (e.g. battering your wife), and these are pervasive (happening in most situations or most of the time or in a repeatable fashion such as each time personal care's delivered), and there's distress to the patient and carer through this, and practical changes haven't improved things, and behavioural changes haven't helped, then I'll consider medication too. I'm not keen on antipsychotics in the first instance since they ramp up risk of serious things (like strokes and death) significantly and invariably the patient's not psychotic (so an antipsychotic's use is contentious). The evidence base increasingly shows that an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor is more effective with less side effects in the management of BPSD than an antipsychotic. If you've Alzheimer's disease. What if you've vascular dementia, or you've Alzheimer's and the drug doesn't work?
Increasingly the evidence suggests that in this patient population (of dementia and BPSD) that a benzodiazepine is a safer and more effective agent than an antipsychotic. Makes sense, too. It's an anxiolytic, it reduces anxiety, it's a "minor tranquilliser" and if someone's distraught through poor memory, or frustration, or through misperception of situations, or misinterpretation of activities/events, or losses, or fears, it helps reduce the anxiety and distress.
On using a benzodiazepine, it's then reviewed by a nurse or myself to see if it works. If it does, huzzah! If not, can it be increased to have a therapeutic trial at a decent dose for a decent duration? Still no benefit? Then it's stopped. We have to do this otherwise I end up writing FP10s forever (which I've not the inclination to do) and my nursing colleagues are locked in to reviewing outcomes forever, which they've neither the capacity nor the need to do. Hence a desire to robustly evaluate effectiveness then determine whether to continue or stop the drug.
A less distraught patient's a good thing, since they feel better and have a lower symptom burden. Too, they're then more likely to accept the reassaurance, reality orientation, personal care or other interventions from carers more successfully, more of the time.
Overall, I'm with the Jobbing Doctor that the NHS can be keen to dish out benzodiazepines too readily, some of the time. But, babies an' bath water, I'd not want to unhelpfully simplify the discussion into use of benzodiazepines is bad, since that's not true. Inappropriate use of benzodiazepines is bad. Rational prescribing practice is not bad. On that basis, within such a framework, I'm far more enthusiastic about a bit of lorazepam than haloperidol/more noxious agents.
The Jobbing Doctor has quite rightly highlighted how mental health can be overly zealous in dishing out lorazepam. Got me thinking.
Bit of a delay in getting an answer to this one since it got me hassling a pharmacist to suss things out for me.
The outcomes were rather heartening.
Most patients prescribed lorazepam within my corner receive it as part of an adjunct to their dementia care. By "most patients" I in fact mean all of them. I have two patients who are prescribed a benzodiazepine for anxiety states. Every other patient on a benzodiazepine is taking it as a part of their package of dementia care.
One lady has anxiety which necessitated hospital in-patient care over many months, she relocated to my corner a few years ago to be near to family and now is on oxazepam 5mg as required. The tablets are 10mg, so it's half a tablet a time. The dose range in older adults is 10mg to 20mg, 3 or 4 times a day. 30mg to 80mg a day, then (which is what she was taking when we first met). She now takes 5mg a couple times a week. At such a tiny dose there's no risk of pharmacological dependence, no problems of side effects. Okay okay, it's homeopathy in all but name, yet for her it's invaluable. She finds that when she's anxious she can take half a tablet, she's in control, it's a key tool for her in her toolbox as part of her anxiety management. Developing an internal locus of control, patient choice, an empowered patient, person centred care, frame it how you will. For her, being able to have a bottle of tablets with just one tablet used up each week is incredibly effective in enabling her to manage her mood state and functional level.
Another lady's had a major adjustment disorder and is currently taking diazepam 2mg half to one tablet once a day. Again, a dose that doesn't cause pharmacological dependence (or side effects for her) but a dose which gives her feelings of relief that she finds necessary to help her cope. And cope she does, now managing activities of daily living that six months ago eluded her. Sure, her CBT and SNRI and twice weekly CPN input are far more meaningful than a sniff of diazepam, but for her the choice of taking a dose (or not) when she wishes is a choice that she feels she needs, a choice that puts her back in control, a choice that enables her to feel she's better equipped to cope.
Other than these two patients, every other prescription for a benzodiazepine since April has been purely as an aid in the management of dementia care. It's not used a lot, at all. We've specialist teams to support care in my corner so if there're problems then the team looks at causes and understanding and interventions, I look at physical comorbidity and concurrent medication, our commonest intervention is stopping drugs not starting them.
I still find it amazing how much medication is used for the right reasons at the right time, but then when dementia progresses the medication's side effect profile and tolerability generate treatment emergent adverse events (e.g. wailing, sobbing, battering carers) which a GP and I can improve upon through review and rationalising a drug regimen.
But if you've dementia, and this advances to cause the inevitable cognitive decline but also non-cognitive changes (i.e. behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia, BPSD), and these are intense (e.g. battering your wife), and these are pervasive (happening in most situations or most of the time or in a repeatable fashion such as each time personal care's delivered), and there's distress to the patient and carer through this, and practical changes haven't improved things, and behavioural changes haven't helped, then I'll consider medication too. I'm not keen on antipsychotics in the first instance since they ramp up risk of serious things (like strokes and death) significantly and invariably the patient's not psychotic (so an antipsychotic's use is contentious). The evidence base increasingly shows that an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor is more effective with less side effects in the management of BPSD than an antipsychotic. If you've Alzheimer's disease. What if you've vascular dementia, or you've Alzheimer's and the drug doesn't work?
Increasingly the evidence suggests that in this patient population (of dementia and BPSD) that a benzodiazepine is a safer and more effective agent than an antipsychotic. Makes sense, too. It's an anxiolytic, it reduces anxiety, it's a "minor tranquilliser" and if someone's distraught through poor memory, or frustration, or through misperception of situations, or misinterpretation of activities/events, or losses, or fears, it helps reduce the anxiety and distress.
On using a benzodiazepine, it's then reviewed by a nurse or myself to see if it works. If it does, huzzah! If not, can it be increased to have a therapeutic trial at a decent dose for a decent duration? Still no benefit? Then it's stopped. We have to do this otherwise I end up writing FP10s forever (which I've not the inclination to do) and my nursing colleagues are locked in to reviewing outcomes forever, which they've neither the capacity nor the need to do. Hence a desire to robustly evaluate effectiveness then determine whether to continue or stop the drug.
A less distraught patient's a good thing, since they feel better and have a lower symptom burden. Too, they're then more likely to accept the reassaurance, reality orientation, personal care or other interventions from carers more successfully, more of the time.
Overall, I'm with the Jobbing Doctor that the NHS can be keen to dish out benzodiazepines too readily, some of the time. But, babies an' bath water, I'd not want to unhelpfully simplify the discussion into use of benzodiazepines is bad, since that's not true. Inappropriate use of benzodiazepines is bad. Rational prescribing practice is not bad. On that basis, within such a framework, I'm far more enthusiastic about a bit of lorazepam than haloperidol/more noxious agents.
Monday, 29 June 2009
Girl on Girl Action
We reviewed a lady in a care home. She was, "causing a disturbance."
She was holding hands with other ladies, talking suggestively, then at times cuddling, stroking and kissing them. She and the other ladies all have advanced dementia.
The care home sought advice on how to manage this.
Knowing my foibles, they'd already looked for delirium, considered diet and fluids and constipation, arranged for a district nurse to do bloods to exclude infection and common physical causes for acute on chronic confusion and sussed out and documented what the circumstances of this behaviour were.
A life long heterosexual woman, with an active libido throughout her life, she sought companionship and intimacy with accessible men.
Her dementia cued her in to selecting men through one principle determinant, which of a fashion makes sense. She'd progress amorous overtures to anyone in trousers.
I don't have a pill to stop that one.
She was holding hands with other ladies, talking suggestively, then at times cuddling, stroking and kissing them. She and the other ladies all have advanced dementia.
The care home sought advice on how to manage this.
Knowing my foibles, they'd already looked for delirium, considered diet and fluids and constipation, arranged for a district nurse to do bloods to exclude infection and common physical causes for acute on chronic confusion and sussed out and documented what the circumstances of this behaviour were.
A life long heterosexual woman, with an active libido throughout her life, she sought companionship and intimacy with accessible men.
Her dementia cued her in to selecting men through one principle determinant, which of a fashion makes sense. She'd progress amorous overtures to anyone in trousers.
I don't have a pill to stop that one.
Thursday, 23 April 2009
Sex
Can people have sex?
Well, yes. Obviously. Or we'd not be here and the world'd be an emptier place. But, if there weren't people then there wouldn't be Pot Noodle, so it wouldn't be all bad.
I chanced upon an article in Slate Magazine today, because I was looking for information on sex. It's with hindsight that it dawned on me that Googling (is that a verb?) for "sex" at work may raise a few eyebrows when the IT server guys see what I came up with. My, human creativity really does know no bounds. I'm so glad I did it all on someone else's computer.
The rationale for finding oh so many sites of oh so many obliging women? Because I don't know enough about sex and older people. Always one to value CPD and a thirst for knowledge and self directed learning, I assiduously studied all I could, online.
Better still, the whole team poured over it all. We didn't learn a lot. I did learn that some of my colleagues know far too much about obscure specialist subjects.
Back to the reason for our diligent search. Sex. Can older people do it?
Really, can they?
No no no, not in a sweaty, physical, swinging from the chandaliers sort of way. In a legal, "Are they allowed to?" sort of way. A tricky matter to disentangle. Googling found far more sites of scantily clad ladies of a certain age than it did of learned legal discourse. There were of course some sites dedicated to lusty, obliging women. And sites dedicated to lawyers. All from the same search. I guess lawyers and prostitutes have more in common than one may first imagine, seeking to use their skills to satisfy their clients for significant amounts of cash.
We've a lady in a care home. She holds hands with a man. They kiss and cuddle. They're both widowed, so single. They're both demented, and are incapacitated adults (within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005, with respect to the decision of an intimate relationship). They like to sleep together. They've sought to have a sexual relationship together.
It's a bit like this.
MCA 2005 directs what can and can't happen, about a great many things (e.g. marriage) but not specifically about sex. Neither does the European Convention of Human Rights, that we could find. Nor did any guidance we rummaged around, on such sites that weren't gloriously lurid.
So, the question remains unanswered. And care homes in my corner take very different views on it "meddling" as they feel wont to do. A definitive answer 'pon desire is desirable. Do older adults have a right to sex?
Well, yes. Obviously. Or we'd not be here and the world'd be an emptier place. But, if there weren't people then there wouldn't be Pot Noodle, so it wouldn't be all bad.
I chanced upon an article in Slate Magazine today, because I was looking for information on sex. It's with hindsight that it dawned on me that Googling (is that a verb?) for "sex" at work may raise a few eyebrows when the IT server guys see what I came up with. My, human creativity really does know no bounds. I'm so glad I did it all on someone else's computer.
The rationale for finding oh so many sites of oh so many obliging women? Because I don't know enough about sex and older people. Always one to value CPD and a thirst for knowledge and self directed learning, I assiduously studied all I could, online.
Better still, the whole team poured over it all. We didn't learn a lot. I did learn that some of my colleagues know far too much about obscure specialist subjects.
Back to the reason for our diligent search. Sex. Can older people do it?
Really, can they?
No no no, not in a sweaty, physical, swinging from the chandaliers sort of way. In a legal, "Are they allowed to?" sort of way. A tricky matter to disentangle. Googling found far more sites of scantily clad ladies of a certain age than it did of learned legal discourse. There were of course some sites dedicated to lusty, obliging women. And sites dedicated to lawyers. All from the same search. I guess lawyers and prostitutes have more in common than one may first imagine, seeking to use their skills to satisfy their clients for significant amounts of cash.
We've a lady in a care home. She holds hands with a man. They kiss and cuddle. They're both widowed, so single. They're both demented, and are incapacitated adults (within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005, with respect to the decision of an intimate relationship). They like to sleep together. They've sought to have a sexual relationship together.
It's a bit like this.
MCA 2005 directs what can and can't happen, about a great many things (e.g. marriage) but not specifically about sex. Neither does the European Convention of Human Rights, that we could find. Nor did any guidance we rummaged around, on such sites that weren't gloriously lurid.
So, the question remains unanswered. And care homes in my corner take very different views on it "meddling" as they feel wont to do. A definitive answer 'pon desire is desirable. Do older adults have a right to sex?
Thursday, 19 March 2009
Cured!
Happy days.
I was referred a gentleman with memory problems, over a couple of years, who had a daughter who, "wanted something doing about it." Unlike Dr Crippen's locale, I read each and every referral letter, even if they're addressed to a CPN or psychologist or social worker. We work as a team, not as individuals in the same building, so I've no qualms in contributing to each and every referral made. Likewise, letters addressed to me are shared with the team every day. People have good ideas. Thoughts are stirred.
I thought this elderly gentlemen had symptoms suggesting Alzheimer's disease and may merit treatment, but he'd had a few falls and was on more drugs that I could count, so a CPN saw him at home first to look at his mood, his function, realistic goals we could achieve, his drug regimen and daughter's input and expectations.
The CPN then met with me that afternoon and talked it through. He was woeful with medication. My CPNs are canny, on this occasion she'd asked about his medication and he'd told her, then she'd checked his account out with the daughter who'd corroborated this. She then looked at the dates on the boxes of pills and realised they should have been replaced. She saw each was for 28 days. Over 365 days, that means a little over 13 requests for repeat prescriptions. The GP surgery confirmed he'd had 8 repeat prescriptions issued in the last 12 months. Ah ha! Suboptimal complicance with medication, another relevant factor. I'm so blessed by savvy CPNs.
So she'd sorted out home care, drugs in a Nomad box for home care to prompt, done a lot of information gathering and assessment but felt, "It wasn't quite right." I saw him at home, with the CPN. It all seemed quite right to me. Elderly man, losing his memory for 3 years, steady decline, increasing periods of confusion. On lots of meds for COPD and OA and prostatism and management of hypertension. One fall of late, no head injury sustained, attributed to joint pain (with NSAIDs bd and co-codamol being used qds to manage this). I spent an hour with him. No worrying symptoms. No new problems, other than his prostatism being more of a nuisance so some more nocturia. No recent infections to destabilise things (with normal WCC and CRP). But my CPN is clever. If she doesn't think it stacks up, there's a high index of suspicion that something's afoot.
I organised a CT brain scan. It showed no vascular damage at all, which for a bloke in his 70's with hypertension necessitating 4 tablets, surprised me. It showed modest atrophy, in keeping with a brain that was 70-odd years old. There were no infracts. There were no space occupying lesions. Phew. There was enlargement of ventricles. Normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH) was suggested.
NPH classically presents with cognitive changes suggesting dementia, urinary incontinence and gait disturbance. I thought his dementia was likely to be through Alzheimer's disease since he had a global, progressive deterioration in all domains consistent with this. I'd put his urinary disturbance down to his prostatism. His gait I'd assumed was antalgic, through his arthritis (and somewhat affected through 240mg codeine a day on top of everything else). I'd not thought of NPH since I'd ascribed other significance to his symptoms.
I referred him on to a neurosurgeon. This happens fairly often. On this occasion the neurosurgeon agreed he had NPH and operated last year. Unusually, things didn't get a fair bit better, they got completely better. His procedural and declarative memory, sequencing, decision making, concentration, praxis, registration and new learning, all ticking along nicely. Fantastic.
I reviewed him. He thanked me enormously for, "being cured."
Okay, I had a small role to play. But really, it was a CPN seeing a pattern that didn't quite fit with Alzheimer's disease progressing over time, then a radiologist seeing atrophic changes but ventricular abnormalities on the CT scan suggesting increased pressure, then a neurosurgeon who fixed it.
But the outcome's excellent. A person's referred with dementia, an incurable condition that'll get worse. They leave, cured. A heartening result, in otherwise chequered times.
I was referred a gentleman with memory problems, over a couple of years, who had a daughter who, "wanted something doing about it." Unlike Dr Crippen's locale, I read each and every referral letter, even if they're addressed to a CPN or psychologist or social worker. We work as a team, not as individuals in the same building, so I've no qualms in contributing to each and every referral made. Likewise, letters addressed to me are shared with the team every day. People have good ideas. Thoughts are stirred.
I thought this elderly gentlemen had symptoms suggesting Alzheimer's disease and may merit treatment, but he'd had a few falls and was on more drugs that I could count, so a CPN saw him at home first to look at his mood, his function, realistic goals we could achieve, his drug regimen and daughter's input and expectations.
The CPN then met with me that afternoon and talked it through. He was woeful with medication. My CPNs are canny, on this occasion she'd asked about his medication and he'd told her, then she'd checked his account out with the daughter who'd corroborated this. She then looked at the dates on the boxes of pills and realised they should have been replaced. She saw each was for 28 days. Over 365 days, that means a little over 13 requests for repeat prescriptions. The GP surgery confirmed he'd had 8 repeat prescriptions issued in the last 12 months. Ah ha! Suboptimal complicance with medication, another relevant factor. I'm so blessed by savvy CPNs.
So she'd sorted out home care, drugs in a Nomad box for home care to prompt, done a lot of information gathering and assessment but felt, "It wasn't quite right." I saw him at home, with the CPN. It all seemed quite right to me. Elderly man, losing his memory for 3 years, steady decline, increasing periods of confusion. On lots of meds for COPD and OA and prostatism and management of hypertension. One fall of late, no head injury sustained, attributed to joint pain (with NSAIDs bd and co-codamol being used qds to manage this). I spent an hour with him. No worrying symptoms. No new problems, other than his prostatism being more of a nuisance so some more nocturia. No recent infections to destabilise things (with normal WCC and CRP). But my CPN is clever. If she doesn't think it stacks up, there's a high index of suspicion that something's afoot.
I organised a CT brain scan. It showed no vascular damage at all, which for a bloke in his 70's with hypertension necessitating 4 tablets, surprised me. It showed modest atrophy, in keeping with a brain that was 70-odd years old. There were no infracts. There were no space occupying lesions. Phew. There was enlargement of ventricles. Normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH) was suggested.
NPH classically presents with cognitive changes suggesting dementia, urinary incontinence and gait disturbance. I thought his dementia was likely to be through Alzheimer's disease since he had a global, progressive deterioration in all domains consistent with this. I'd put his urinary disturbance down to his prostatism. His gait I'd assumed was antalgic, through his arthritis (and somewhat affected through 240mg codeine a day on top of everything else). I'd not thought of NPH since I'd ascribed other significance to his symptoms.
I referred him on to a neurosurgeon. This happens fairly often. On this occasion the neurosurgeon agreed he had NPH and operated last year. Unusually, things didn't get a fair bit better, they got completely better. His procedural and declarative memory, sequencing, decision making, concentration, praxis, registration and new learning, all ticking along nicely. Fantastic.
I reviewed him. He thanked me enormously for, "being cured."
Okay, I had a small role to play. But really, it was a CPN seeing a pattern that didn't quite fit with Alzheimer's disease progressing over time, then a radiologist seeing atrophic changes but ventricular abnormalities on the CT scan suggesting increased pressure, then a neurosurgeon who fixed it.
But the outcome's excellent. A person's referred with dementia, an incurable condition that'll get worse. They leave, cured. A heartening result, in otherwise chequered times.
Friday, 6 March 2009
Rewards
Mr Edwards went to a cafe in a charming garden centre today, then walked around looking at the bedding plants, enjoying the riot of colour. I know this because a support worker relayed to me how cheery he was, ambling about seemingly aimlessly, chattering away to her with real zeal and passion. Mr Edwards has always been an enthusiastic gardener.
He has Parkinsons Disease (PD) which affects him in three particular ways.
Firstly, his speech sounds slurred. Although he's readily understood he's very self conscious of this because he reckons he doesn't sound like himself but worse, he reckons he sounds drunk. Happen he's right. I don't think his dysarthria sounds like drunken slurred speech, but I'm tuned in to medicalising stuff and in critiquing nuances of speech that means I sift through a number of reasons why he's slurring speech whilst folk in his neighbourhood would instead probably assume he's drunk. He lives in a hellishly deprived area. It's a statement of fact that lots of people are drunk lots of the time. He feels awfully self conscious that, if he speaks, folk will presume he's a drunken sot.
Secondly, his gait is poor. He staggers and sometimes falls. Steps are a nightmare for him. This compounds his belief that folk will see him as drunk. It also concerns him, whilst he's out and about, that he might freeze or fall in an awkward place. Tragically, he's not fearful that he'll come to harm through this, no, he's fearful that someone else will. He's terrified he could collapse in the road and cause someone to swerve and have an accident, all because of him.
Thirdly, as sadly everyone with PD will if they live long enough, he has developed dementia. It's expected and inevitable, PD is a progressive neurodegenerative disease so only goes one way, but for Mr Edwards his dementia's responding well to medication and he's just a little muddled with dates, a little forgetful of times (was it 2 days ago we last met up, or was it a week?) and a little impaired with recent declarative memory. Procedural memory, such as riding his bike to his allotment, is fine. So's managing finances. Orientation in his locale is fine (he's lived there all his life so knows his way around effortlessly). Judgement/decision making is still sound and has improved significantly on galantamine.
An Occupational Therapist sorted some practical changes for him, both in his home and his allotment and with tools. A Social Worker sorted out practical support, with a care package of home carers twice a day. A clever and devoted chap within our local Alzheimers Society branch has sorted out his benefits and finances. Nurses in our memory clinic have done exhaustive memory testing initially (to inform diagnosis) and periodically (to assess efficacy/effects of galantamine). A CPN gave advice to him and to his PD Nurse, several times, over a period of a month or so, with oodles of practical changes made consequent to this. She then did some CBT with him over four months. Yes yes, I know he's got dementia, but that doesn't preclude CBT. Indeed the behavioural stuff and experiential learning over a month or so, with a fortuitous ability to forget the bad things in the months before this, meant Mr Edwards regained significant confidence and competence through the CBT. Underpinning this, a Support Worker has been assisting him in maintaining function (e.g. going to his allotment, going to shops, using a bus for journies he can't cycle, going to his GP and hospital appointments for things that he'd been putting off, visiting friends he'd worked with for decades, getting to church).
I saw him at his home with a CPN (and the results of her initial assessment) and memory clinic assessment, the PD Nurse's referral details, the subsequent GP referral letter and blood results and the results of the CT imaging and ECG I'd requested. We'd considered a DAT scan but it wasn't necessary. I spoke to him at length, assessed his mental state, assessed areas of cognition that had been equivocal on memory clinic testing and reviewed all the results. The diagnosis was obvious. He had PD dementia.
We discuss options. It doesn't take long. My colleagues have already paved the way to this point, with ongoing discussion at each stage, by each person, so my words are simply the concluding confirmation, the distilled summary.
In my corner it's only Consultant Psychiatrists who start acetylcholinesterase inhibitor treatment, so having discussed medication out comes an FP10 and we start galantamine.
I've not seen him since. I hear about him several times a week, through working in the same office as the Support Worker and CPN. In his care I've been involved in over 20 conversations, from dicussions at the point of referral then assessment then intervention. I've consistently directed and influenced his care. But in terms of face to face contact, in truth, it's the support worker and CPN who've effected change and in his words, "Given me my life back."
Yet, this week, he gave the Support Worker a gift wrapped bottle of wine and card to give to me. The unqualified Support Worker has done the most work, yet she didn't get anything. The qualified nurse (a CPN) has done the next most amount of work, yet she didn't get anything.
I have a series of conversations with staff and see him once. I can't claim that's a lot of work.
Doesn't seem quite fair.
He has Parkinsons Disease (PD) which affects him in three particular ways.
Firstly, his speech sounds slurred. Although he's readily understood he's very self conscious of this because he reckons he doesn't sound like himself but worse, he reckons he sounds drunk. Happen he's right. I don't think his dysarthria sounds like drunken slurred speech, but I'm tuned in to medicalising stuff and in critiquing nuances of speech that means I sift through a number of reasons why he's slurring speech whilst folk in his neighbourhood would instead probably assume he's drunk. He lives in a hellishly deprived area. It's a statement of fact that lots of people are drunk lots of the time. He feels awfully self conscious that, if he speaks, folk will presume he's a drunken sot.
Secondly, his gait is poor. He staggers and sometimes falls. Steps are a nightmare for him. This compounds his belief that folk will see him as drunk. It also concerns him, whilst he's out and about, that he might freeze or fall in an awkward place. Tragically, he's not fearful that he'll come to harm through this, no, he's fearful that someone else will. He's terrified he could collapse in the road and cause someone to swerve and have an accident, all because of him.
Thirdly, as sadly everyone with PD will if they live long enough, he has developed dementia. It's expected and inevitable, PD is a progressive neurodegenerative disease so only goes one way, but for Mr Edwards his dementia's responding well to medication and he's just a little muddled with dates, a little forgetful of times (was it 2 days ago we last met up, or was it a week?) and a little impaired with recent declarative memory. Procedural memory, such as riding his bike to his allotment, is fine. So's managing finances. Orientation in his locale is fine (he's lived there all his life so knows his way around effortlessly). Judgement/decision making is still sound and has improved significantly on galantamine.
An Occupational Therapist sorted some practical changes for him, both in his home and his allotment and with tools. A Social Worker sorted out practical support, with a care package of home carers twice a day. A clever and devoted chap within our local Alzheimers Society branch has sorted out his benefits and finances. Nurses in our memory clinic have done exhaustive memory testing initially (to inform diagnosis) and periodically (to assess efficacy/effects of galantamine). A CPN gave advice to him and to his PD Nurse, several times, over a period of a month or so, with oodles of practical changes made consequent to this. She then did some CBT with him over four months. Yes yes, I know he's got dementia, but that doesn't preclude CBT. Indeed the behavioural stuff and experiential learning over a month or so, with a fortuitous ability to forget the bad things in the months before this, meant Mr Edwards regained significant confidence and competence through the CBT. Underpinning this, a Support Worker has been assisting him in maintaining function (e.g. going to his allotment, going to shops, using a bus for journies he can't cycle, going to his GP and hospital appointments for things that he'd been putting off, visiting friends he'd worked with for decades, getting to church).
I saw him at his home with a CPN (and the results of her initial assessment) and memory clinic assessment, the PD Nurse's referral details, the subsequent GP referral letter and blood results and the results of the CT imaging and ECG I'd requested. We'd considered a DAT scan but it wasn't necessary. I spoke to him at length, assessed his mental state, assessed areas of cognition that had been equivocal on memory clinic testing and reviewed all the results. The diagnosis was obvious. He had PD dementia.
We discuss options. It doesn't take long. My colleagues have already paved the way to this point, with ongoing discussion at each stage, by each person, so my words are simply the concluding confirmation, the distilled summary.
In my corner it's only Consultant Psychiatrists who start acetylcholinesterase inhibitor treatment, so having discussed medication out comes an FP10 and we start galantamine.
I've not seen him since. I hear about him several times a week, through working in the same office as the Support Worker and CPN. In his care I've been involved in over 20 conversations, from dicussions at the point of referral then assessment then intervention. I've consistently directed and influenced his care. But in terms of face to face contact, in truth, it's the support worker and CPN who've effected change and in his words, "Given me my life back."
Yet, this week, he gave the Support Worker a gift wrapped bottle of wine and card to give to me. The unqualified Support Worker has done the most work, yet she didn't get anything. The qualified nurse (a CPN) has done the next most amount of work, yet she didn't get anything.
I have a series of conversations with staff and see him once. I can't claim that's a lot of work.
Doesn't seem quite fair.
Friday, 20 February 2009
Old Age Services
Our National Dementia Strategy is a document I've already commented upon this month, but this little gem raised my spirits so has to be shared.
It basically says, right on the last page of the whole strategy (just before the appendicies) that specialist mental health services for older adults should not be dismantled, absorbed into generic "depression" and "schizophrenia" and other "modular" general adult services, but should remain as they are and grow stronger. Hurrah!
You'll find it in chapter 6, page 74, of the full strategy document. In case you don't have it to hand, here it is in full :
"Implementation of this Strategy will need to be part of a broader focus on older people’s mental health services. Strong concerns were raised during the consultation exercise that some localities may be interpreting age equality in mental health services to mean a ‘one size fits all ages’ approach. This generally means using existing working-age adult services to look after older people with functional illness. With reflection, this is much more likely to increase age discrimination than it is to address it. This is because age here is a proxy for a different set of needs and therefore skills. Equivalent quality of care is likely to require enhancing current older people’s mental health teams to have higher levels of functionality in terms of the capacity for assertive outreach, for example. This would benefit those with dementia as well as those older people with functional disorder. The improvement of services for people with dementia must not be used as an excuse for diluting specialist services for older people with other mental health needs."
It basically says, right on the last page of the whole strategy (just before the appendicies) that specialist mental health services for older adults should not be dismantled, absorbed into generic "depression" and "schizophrenia" and other "modular" general adult services, but should remain as they are and grow stronger. Hurrah!
You'll find it in chapter 6, page 74, of the full strategy document. In case you don't have it to hand, here it is in full :
"Implementation of this Strategy will need to be part of a broader focus on older people’s mental health services. Strong concerns were raised during the consultation exercise that some localities may be interpreting age equality in mental health services to mean a ‘one size fits all ages’ approach. This generally means using existing working-age adult services to look after older people with functional illness. With reflection, this is much more likely to increase age discrimination than it is to address it. This is because age here is a proxy for a different set of needs and therefore skills. Equivalent quality of care is likely to require enhancing current older people’s mental health teams to have higher levels of functionality in terms of the capacity for assertive outreach, for example. This would benefit those with dementia as well as those older people with functional disorder. The improvement of services for people with dementia must not be used as an excuse for diluting specialist services for older people with other mental health needs."
Saturday, 14 February 2009
Shock news!
You will not be startled to learn the results of the DART-AD trial.
The reason why we've Prescription Only Medicine (POM) is that it's thought to be, ". . . those preparations that are available only on a prescription issued by an appropriate practitioner."
It's the proper stuff. Stuff with risks and benefits. Stuff with real consequences (both good and bad). Rather than Over The Counter (OTC) medicine which anyone can get, over the counter, from a chemist, POM tends to be medication where risks, side effects, treatment emergent adverse events, monitoring, serious interactions or other elements of how the drug works needs careful thought and judgement made.
Hence the legal requirement for not just advice, not just safety netting and input from a manager or a scientist, these proper drugs require, "an appropriate practitioner."
A good turn of phrase, that. "An" suggests one, which pleases me. One GP (not polyclinics and walk in centres). One psychiatrist (not fractured models of a Community one, an Early Intervention one, a Crisis Resolution one, an Inpatient one, a Rehabilitation one etc etc). Optimistic, I know, but having one GP and one Consultant is a model I'm thoroughly wedded to.
"Appropriate" is a handy word, meaning that it's not just a practitioner, it's got to be an appropriate one. The pharmacist in my team's clear on what this means. It means someone who can make valid, rational prescribing decisions. Although, as a pharamcist, there's expertise in the drug's use and interactions, pharmacists don't do out-patient clinics so don't get to see all the consequences of medication used, so don't feel they're experts at prescribing. Sensibly, my pharmacist sees herself as a resource to inform on decisions (and explain medication issues to patients, and manage the governance systems around medicines management), she doesn't see herself as an "appropriate" prescriber.
The word "practitioner" is salient, too. It implies a need for someone in practice, someone practising clinical care. So not just someone who knows a lot about drugs, then. If asked, "Of the last 50 patients you gave advice on medication to, how many had no side effects (and you've documented that), and how many had side effects (which you've documented)?" a "practitioner" should be in a position to answer that, someone just giving advice couldn't. And if that someone's giving prescribing advice but not seeing the consequences of their clinical practice, then I'd suggest they're not "an appropriate practitioner" so should not be issuing prescriptions for Prescription Only Medicine.
Rant over.
POM are medicines that we shouldn't be cavalier with. They're drugs which have real effects, so often need judicious consideration on initiating, continuing, monitoring and withdrawing them.
Which brings me to this study. It's a good study. It's funded by the UK Alzheimer's Research Trust, not a drug company. It's a study that was conducted over an appropriate length of time. Each treatment arm was of a decent size. It's a very relevant research topic.
They looked at folk with Alzheimer's disease, for up to 3 years. They found that patients without antipsychotic medication lived longer than patients with antipsychotic medication. Shock news!
I'm ambivalent about this study, really. On the one hand, it's a well executed bit of credible research that's about a contentious and relevant theme. On the other hand, is it necessary?
In patients with crashing heart failure, with fluid pouring into their lungs, the dread and feeling of drowning, the weakness, then death, life isn't great. Diamorphine can be used to reduce the ghastly symptoms. Diamorphine causes respiratory depression. Stops you breathing. In a patient who's lungs are filling with fluid, reducing their breathing isn't a strategy conducive to a long life. But it's done, rightly, even though life may be shortened, because the clinical condition warrants this palliative care. Is a study necessary to show us that, in heart failure, patients dying without diamorphine live fractionally longer than patients on diamorphine? Probably not. We know diamorphine is a proper drug, a medicine with benefits and side effects that need to be weighed by "an appropriate practitioner."
The DART-AD trial shows us that antipsychotics generate risk in Alzheimer's Disease patients. Although my gut reaction is, "And?!" I do s'pose it's useful to have a well executed study evidencing that what we knew to be the case is actually the case.
So is there anything from this which will change my clinical practice? No. But it's good to know that what I thought (that the drugs were dangerous) is true, and decisions around their use should be very carefully throught through by senior clinicians with expertise in this area.
The reason why we've Prescription Only Medicine (POM) is that it's thought to be, ". . . those preparations that are available only on a prescription issued by an appropriate practitioner."
It's the proper stuff. Stuff with risks and benefits. Stuff with real consequences (both good and bad). Rather than Over The Counter (OTC) medicine which anyone can get, over the counter, from a chemist, POM tends to be medication where risks, side effects, treatment emergent adverse events, monitoring, serious interactions or other elements of how the drug works needs careful thought and judgement made.
Hence the legal requirement for not just advice, not just safety netting and input from a manager or a scientist, these proper drugs require, "an appropriate practitioner."
A good turn of phrase, that. "An" suggests one, which pleases me. One GP (not polyclinics and walk in centres). One psychiatrist (not fractured models of a Community one, an Early Intervention one, a Crisis Resolution one, an Inpatient one, a Rehabilitation one etc etc). Optimistic, I know, but having one GP and one Consultant is a model I'm thoroughly wedded to.
"Appropriate" is a handy word, meaning that it's not just a practitioner, it's got to be an appropriate one. The pharmacist in my team's clear on what this means. It means someone who can make valid, rational prescribing decisions. Although, as a pharamcist, there's expertise in the drug's use and interactions, pharmacists don't do out-patient clinics so don't get to see all the consequences of medication used, so don't feel they're experts at prescribing. Sensibly, my pharmacist sees herself as a resource to inform on decisions (and explain medication issues to patients, and manage the governance systems around medicines management), she doesn't see herself as an "appropriate" prescriber.
The word "practitioner" is salient, too. It implies a need for someone in practice, someone practising clinical care. So not just someone who knows a lot about drugs, then. If asked, "Of the last 50 patients you gave advice on medication to, how many had no side effects (and you've documented that), and how many had side effects (which you've documented)?" a "practitioner" should be in a position to answer that, someone just giving advice couldn't. And if that someone's giving prescribing advice but not seeing the consequences of their clinical practice, then I'd suggest they're not "an appropriate practitioner" so should not be issuing prescriptions for Prescription Only Medicine.
Rant over.
POM are medicines that we shouldn't be cavalier with. They're drugs which have real effects, so often need judicious consideration on initiating, continuing, monitoring and withdrawing them.
Which brings me to this study. It's a good study. It's funded by the UK Alzheimer's Research Trust, not a drug company. It's a study that was conducted over an appropriate length of time. Each treatment arm was of a decent size. It's a very relevant research topic.
They looked at folk with Alzheimer's disease, for up to 3 years. They found that patients without antipsychotic medication lived longer than patients with antipsychotic medication. Shock news!
I'm ambivalent about this study, really. On the one hand, it's a well executed bit of credible research that's about a contentious and relevant theme. On the other hand, is it necessary?
In patients with crashing heart failure, with fluid pouring into their lungs, the dread and feeling of drowning, the weakness, then death, life isn't great. Diamorphine can be used to reduce the ghastly symptoms. Diamorphine causes respiratory depression. Stops you breathing. In a patient who's lungs are filling with fluid, reducing their breathing isn't a strategy conducive to a long life. But it's done, rightly, even though life may be shortened, because the clinical condition warrants this palliative care. Is a study necessary to show us that, in heart failure, patients dying without diamorphine live fractionally longer than patients on diamorphine? Probably not. We know diamorphine is a proper drug, a medicine with benefits and side effects that need to be weighed by "an appropriate practitioner."
The DART-AD trial shows us that antipsychotics generate risk in Alzheimer's Disease patients. Although my gut reaction is, "And?!" I do s'pose it's useful to have a well executed study evidencing that what we knew to be the case is actually the case.
So is there anything from this which will change my clinical practice? No. But it's good to know that what I thought (that the drugs were dangerous) is true, and decisions around their use should be very carefully throught through by senior clinicians with expertise in this area.
Monday, 9 February 2009
Healing Hands
One lady in a care home, with advanced dementia, has a rather feisty disposition. Her daughter's more vehement in her assertions, saying, "She's a vile creature, she's always been evil, really evil!"
As her dementia has progressed, so her frontal lobe function's deteriorated and she's become more disinhibited, her natural demeanour has come to the fore, with any veneer of civility or decorum being long lost, now.
The care home staff describe her as being an active soul. She fills her time to her amusement and satisfaction, "Tormenting other residents with wicked words and abuse," through throwing food she doesn't like from her plate onto the floor, or at carers, grinning as she does so, snatching food from other folks plates if she wants it, saying hurtful things just to get a response, "That's your daughter going, is she? Must be bored with you, what with you saying the same things to her all the time, I expect she's glad to be away."
My nursing colleagues saw her a number of times. I saw her once to establish diagnosis, capacity and exclude a treatable mood disorder.
I use risperidone as a depot medication for a number of folk but I can't think, in the last couple years, of anyone I've prescribed oral risperidone for. My nursing colleague discussed this lady's presentation with me and sought to start a low dose of oral risperidone. She persuaded me it was a reasonable plan to try then review, so we did. She also gave the home advice on how to handle this lady's interesting presentation.
Just 2 weeks on when she was reviewed, the care home staff say she's cured! All the malicious talk's stopped. She's still swearing like a trooper and nipping and scratching when staff try and help her bathe, but she's no longer biting. At meals and in the lounge she watches everything and grins to herself but can now bite her tongue and remain, if not prosocial, at least asocial rather than being antisocial.
A good result.
As her dementia has progressed, so her frontal lobe function's deteriorated and she's become more disinhibited, her natural demeanour has come to the fore, with any veneer of civility or decorum being long lost, now.
The care home staff describe her as being an active soul. She fills her time to her amusement and satisfaction, "Tormenting other residents with wicked words and abuse," through throwing food she doesn't like from her plate onto the floor, or at carers, grinning as she does so, snatching food from other folks plates if she wants it, saying hurtful things just to get a response, "That's your daughter going, is she? Must be bored with you, what with you saying the same things to her all the time, I expect she's glad to be away."
My nursing colleagues saw her a number of times. I saw her once to establish diagnosis, capacity and exclude a treatable mood disorder.
I use risperidone as a depot medication for a number of folk but I can't think, in the last couple years, of anyone I've prescribed oral risperidone for. My nursing colleague discussed this lady's presentation with me and sought to start a low dose of oral risperidone. She persuaded me it was a reasonable plan to try then review, so we did. She also gave the home advice on how to handle this lady's interesting presentation.
Just 2 weeks on when she was reviewed, the care home staff say she's cured! All the malicious talk's stopped. She's still swearing like a trooper and nipping and scratching when staff try and help her bathe, but she's no longer biting. At meals and in the lounge she watches everything and grins to herself but can now bite her tongue and remain, if not prosocial, at least asocial rather than being antisocial.
A good result.
Friday, 6 February 2009
Incandescent
My normally calm and affable disposition has been perturbed. Why? Because of this (which I chance upon here).
Oh my giddy aunt, where do I begin?
I agree that elderly abuse is common, undetected and poorly addressed. We have a "new" law for this, now. The Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 44 (2), criminalises both ill treatment and willful neglect of incapacitated folk which can result in imprisonment for up to 5 years and a fine. We don't need new laws, we need CSCI and statutory organisations (in health and social care) having strength to highlight this then for it to be addressed.
I can't think of a month, through the last year, where I've not been involved in elderly abuse proceedings. It's commonly seen and flagged up in my corner. Police have a nigh on impossible task of generating evidence "beyond all reasonable doubt" when elderly incapacitated folk are involved. They're honest about this. Last time I was at a High Court for a protection case, the CPS barrister met with me and asked how sure I was about the patient's account, given he had advanced dementia. I explained that the detail could contain erroneous elements but that his account of what grossly trainspired was internally consistent, repeatedly stated with the same content, coherent, fitted with informant and corroborating history/evidence, fitted with the contusions/abrasions and injuries sustained so I saw the minor nuances of flux in his account as inconsequential and that I was 95% sure the account was valid. 95% still left 5% doubt, she said. Not good enough. She met with the judge and it never even went to trial.
Laws alone won't help. We have the laws. We need surveillance, intervention and sanctions if we're to effect change.
Picking on the issue of antipsychotics and running parallels to prescribing this in dementia care as being a criminal act, what?!
Frankly, this just really, really pissed me off. Antipsychotics shouldn't be used first line in dementia care. Or second line. But they can have a place. Babies and bathwater. We don't want to say that there's no patient with dementia who could ever benefit from an antipsychotic. Some experience psychosis. Some benefit from an antipsychotic. Antipsychotic are not placebo. They're proper drugs, with real risks and real side effects. These are serious (eg a 2% increase of a year of having a stroke). Of course, if you're psychotic and tormented and won't live a year, a 98% chance of not having a stroke but getting relief may p'raps have some appeal . . .
Every patient in care homes in my corner gets reviewed. By me. They're not my patients. Most of the time I've not started the medication. But I still believe antipsychotics are such risky drugs and dementia care needs such support that it's worth my time visiting each and every care home in my patch, going through each and every MARS sheet for every resident and ensuring there's rational prescribing for all of them. I see this as good clinical practice. My GPs see this as a useful service, meaning care home patients receive appropriate Consultant Psychiatrist input into their drug regimens without having to refer every care home resident to me. Most of the time I am stopping antipsychotics. Very rarely, I start them. Sometimes I fiddle with the dose. I try and ensure that there's appropriate patient centred care - every patient gets due consideration of the risks, benefits and appropriateness of medication for them, with their history, at that stage in their illness. I would suggest that this is one element of decent clinical care. I do not think that what I am doing is wayward, let alone criminal.
Oft times GPs are called out of hours or at weekends and the "on call" GP has to take a view on how to support a care home with an "unmanageable" patient they don't know, in a care home they don't know, managed by staff they don't know. The GP has no idea on what training the staff have and on what they should be able to manage. GPs try and be helpful. GPs hear care home staff say their resident is battering other folk and "needs medication" so often feel obliged to prescribe. It makes sense for me and my team to then review care.
I have no hospital in-patients at present. This is largely because EMI Nursing Homes accept my patients knowing that nursing staff and I support them, a lot, with frequent visits and use of Continuing Care for 1:1 care so they can adequately staff their units and that use of medication is easily and appropriately reviewed. Use of antipsychotics is a small but important part of care for some patients some of the time. I'm much in favour of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors, I use benzodiazepines, but sometimes, just sometimes, an antipsychotic is appropriate.
What's being proposed?
Patients without dementia can have antipsychotics.
Patients in their own houses can have antipsychotics.
Patients with dementia can not have antipsychotics.
Patients in care homes can not have antipsychotics.
Erm . . . isn't this blatantly flagrant prejudice?
Politicians offering either "guidance" to clinicians or criminalising clinical care is so so missing the point.
The newspaper goes on to say that the issue is of poor detection by Social Services and poor resourcing (with a predicted £6billion funding gap). Well then, there we are. Use the MCA 2005 if we need legal redress but let's crack on and look at malign care in care homes/institutions, CSCI's role (and teeth), CPS guidance on when to go to trial, training and support for care home staff. Then, critically, look at the lack of resourcing which has generated this system. I'll say it again. We don't need more laws. We need surveillance, intervention and sanctions if we're to effect change.
Oh my giddy aunt, where do I begin?
I agree that elderly abuse is common, undetected and poorly addressed. We have a "new" law for this, now. The Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 44 (2), criminalises both ill treatment and willful neglect of incapacitated folk which can result in imprisonment for up to 5 years and a fine. We don't need new laws, we need CSCI and statutory organisations (in health and social care) having strength to highlight this then for it to be addressed.
I can't think of a month, through the last year, where I've not been involved in elderly abuse proceedings. It's commonly seen and flagged up in my corner. Police have a nigh on impossible task of generating evidence "beyond all reasonable doubt" when elderly incapacitated folk are involved. They're honest about this. Last time I was at a High Court for a protection case, the CPS barrister met with me and asked how sure I was about the patient's account, given he had advanced dementia. I explained that the detail could contain erroneous elements but that his account of what grossly trainspired was internally consistent, repeatedly stated with the same content, coherent, fitted with informant and corroborating history/evidence, fitted with the contusions/abrasions and injuries sustained so I saw the minor nuances of flux in his account as inconsequential and that I was 95% sure the account was valid. 95% still left 5% doubt, she said. Not good enough. She met with the judge and it never even went to trial.
Laws alone won't help. We have the laws. We need surveillance, intervention and sanctions if we're to effect change.
Picking on the issue of antipsychotics and running parallels to prescribing this in dementia care as being a criminal act, what?!
Frankly, this just really, really pissed me off. Antipsychotics shouldn't be used first line in dementia care. Or second line. But they can have a place. Babies and bathwater. We don't want to say that there's no patient with dementia who could ever benefit from an antipsychotic. Some experience psychosis. Some benefit from an antipsychotic. Antipsychotic are not placebo. They're proper drugs, with real risks and real side effects. These are serious (eg a 2% increase of a year of having a stroke). Of course, if you're psychotic and tormented and won't live a year, a 98% chance of not having a stroke but getting relief may p'raps have some appeal . . .
Every patient in care homes in my corner gets reviewed. By me. They're not my patients. Most of the time I've not started the medication. But I still believe antipsychotics are such risky drugs and dementia care needs such support that it's worth my time visiting each and every care home in my patch, going through each and every MARS sheet for every resident and ensuring there's rational prescribing for all of them. I see this as good clinical practice. My GPs see this as a useful service, meaning care home patients receive appropriate Consultant Psychiatrist input into their drug regimens without having to refer every care home resident to me. Most of the time I am stopping antipsychotics. Very rarely, I start them. Sometimes I fiddle with the dose. I try and ensure that there's appropriate patient centred care - every patient gets due consideration of the risks, benefits and appropriateness of medication for them, with their history, at that stage in their illness. I would suggest that this is one element of decent clinical care. I do not think that what I am doing is wayward, let alone criminal.
Oft times GPs are called out of hours or at weekends and the "on call" GP has to take a view on how to support a care home with an "unmanageable" patient they don't know, in a care home they don't know, managed by staff they don't know. The GP has no idea on what training the staff have and on what they should be able to manage. GPs try and be helpful. GPs hear care home staff say their resident is battering other folk and "needs medication" so often feel obliged to prescribe. It makes sense for me and my team to then review care.
I have no hospital in-patients at present. This is largely because EMI Nursing Homes accept my patients knowing that nursing staff and I support them, a lot, with frequent visits and use of Continuing Care for 1:1 care so they can adequately staff their units and that use of medication is easily and appropriately reviewed. Use of antipsychotics is a small but important part of care for some patients some of the time. I'm much in favour of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors, I use benzodiazepines, but sometimes, just sometimes, an antipsychotic is appropriate.
What's being proposed?
Patients without dementia can have antipsychotics.
Patients in their own houses can have antipsychotics.
Patients with dementia can not have antipsychotics.
Patients in care homes can not have antipsychotics.
Erm . . . isn't this blatantly flagrant prejudice?
Politicians offering either "guidance" to clinicians or criminalising clinical care is so so missing the point.
The newspaper goes on to say that the issue is of poor detection by Social Services and poor resourcing (with a predicted £6billion funding gap). Well then, there we are. Use the MCA 2005 if we need legal redress but let's crack on and look at malign care in care homes/institutions, CSCI's role (and teeth), CPS guidance on when to go to trial, training and support for care home staff. Then, critically, look at the lack of resourcing which has generated this system. I'll say it again. We don't need more laws. We need surveillance, intervention and sanctions if we're to effect change.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)